Whole brisket with butter-rub injection and an onion-garlic marinade, smoked low and slow and served with its juices.
Cook Time 20 hourshours
Marinating (minimum) 12 hourshours
Servings 16servings
Author Jeff Phillips
Ingredients
Brisket and Onion Marinade
1whole packer brisketabout 13 lb; point and flat attached
2medium yellow onions
10garlic cloves
6heaping tablespoonsJeff's original rubplus more for seasoning
16ozbeef brothapproximately, for the drip pan
Butter Injection
2stickssalted butter1/2 lb
2tablespoonsJeff's original rubground finely if possible
Optional Juice Substitute (If Drippings Were Not Saved)
1stickbutter
1cupbeef broth
2tablespoonsJeff's original rub
Instructions
Prepare and Marinate
Trim the brisket fat cap to about 1/8–1/4 inch. Save the trimmed fat in the refrigerator for the smoker.
Melt the injection butter, stir in the finely ground rub and inject throughout the brisket, moving about 2 inches between injection sites. Keep stirring the mixture so the rub does not settle.
Process the onions, garlic and 6 heaping tablespoons rub into a smooth marinade. Place the brisket fat side down in a pan, spread the marinade over the top and sides, cover and refrigerate at least 12 hours.
Before smoking, sprinkle a little more rub over the brisket without washing off the onion marinade.
Smoke and Serve
Prepare the smoker to maintain about 225°F, avoiding temperatures above roughly 235–240°F during the cook.
Place the brisket fat side down on a center rack, a drip pan beneath it and the saved trimmed fat on a rack above it to baste as it renders.
Smoke about 18–20 hours for a 13 lb brisket, allowing extra time for weather and the stall. Add smoke for about 8–10 hours or half the estimated cooking time.
When needed, add about 16 oz beef broth to the drip pan to prevent the drippings burning.
At about 165°F internal, either leave the brisket unwrapped, wrap it in foil, or move it into the pan of juices and cover the pan. Covered methods soften the bark.
Continue until at least 185°F and tender; the author generally finishes at about 195°F.
Rest about 30 minutes. Slice across the grain, adjusting slice thickness to tenderness.
Defat the collected juices and spoon over the slices or serve alongside. If no juices were saved, melt and mix the optional butter, broth and rub substitute.
Notes
Estimated yield: 16 generous servings from a 13 lb raw packer after trimming and cooking loss. Cooking time is a planning estimate of about 20 hours; the author's weather-affected cook took 25 hours. Refrigerated marinating takes at least 12 hours more. The source's onion-marinade sentence is incomplete; the card combines the onions, garlic and rub listed in its ingredients and retains the stated puree/marinating method. The injection is separate from the onion marinade.