Baby Back vs. Spare vs. St. Louis Ribs: Which Should You Buy?

Smoking-Meat.com is supported by its readers. We may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you if you buy through a link on this page.

Standing in front of the pork ribs at the grocery store can be a little confusing when baby backs, spare ribs and St. Louis ribs are all sitting there with different prices and very little explanation. They will all make good barbecue, but knowing what you are buying helps you compare the value, plan the preparation and choose a recipe that fits the rack you bring home.

The first thing to understand is that St. Louis ribs are trimmed spare ribs, while baby backs come from a different part of the rib cage. That makes the choice a little simpler, since you are really deciding between back ribs and spare ribs, then deciding how much trimming you want to do yourself.

Baby Back Ribs

Baby backs come from near the backbone, where the ribs meet the loin, and you may also see them labeled loin back ribs or simply back ribs. The bones are shorter and more curved than spare rib bones, which gives the rack its familiar rounded shape.

The amount of meat left on top varies quite a bit, and some racks carry a thick layer of loin meat while others are more evenly trimmed. More meat sounds like an automatic improvement, but a very thick section next to a thin end can make the rack harder to cook evenly, particularly if that lean top layer dries before the meat between the bones becomes tender.

Choose a rack with fairly even coverage and enough meat over the bones that you are buying something worth cooking. If you like this cut, you can find several different approaches in my baby back rib recipes.

Spare Ribs

Spare ribs come from farther down the rib cage toward the belly and tend to have longer, flatter bones, with an irregular section of cartilage, meat and rib tips along one edge. A full slab may also have a flap of meat on the bone side that you can remove and cook separately.

These ribs generally have more fat and connective tissue than back ribs and do well with enough cooking time to become tender. You can smoke the full slab as it comes, or trim it into a more uniform St. Louis rack, depending on how you want to prepare and serve it.

The lower price per pound can make full spares attractive, but remember that the package includes pieces you may trim away from the serving rack. Those pieces are still useful food if you cook them as rib tips, so the value depends partly on whether you want to use the whole purchase.

St. Louis Style Ribs

St. Louis ribs start as spare ribs, with the breastbone area, cartilage-heavy tip section and irregular edges trimmed away to make a more rectangular rack. You get the character of spare ribs with less preparation, and the shape makes them convenient for laying out on the smoker and slicing into fairly consistent servings.

They are often my recommendation for someone who wants a straightforward first rack, since there is less trimming to figure out and no need to work around the tip section at serving time. You will usually pay something for that convenience, so compare the actual racks and prices rather than assuming the pretrimmed package is always the better buy.

If you would rather buy full spares and do the trimming yourself, my spare rib trimming guide walks through it using photographs from my rib cooks.

Compare the Cuts

Cut	What You Are Buying	Preparation	What to Keep in Mind
Baby backs	Shorter, curved ribs from near the loin	Usually light trimming and membrane removal	Thick loin meat can change cooking time and moisture
Full spare ribs	Larger slab with the rib tip and cartilage section attached	Smoke whole or trim St. Louis style	Save the trimmings and allow space for the larger slab
St. Louis ribs	Spare ribs trimmed into a rectangular rack	Usually little trimming beyond a final inspection	Convenient shape, with the same general cooking needs as spare ribs

What to Look For in Any Rack

Look for fairly even thickness, good meat coverage and a package that is intact and properly chilled. Avoid racks with large stretches of exposed bone on the meat side, which are often called shiners, because those areas have already lost much of the meat you want to eat.

A little variation is normal, and you do not need to reject a good rack over a small thin spot. If you are cooking several racks together, though, buying similar cuts and thicknesses makes the cook easier to manage than mixing a small, thin baby back with a thick spare rack and expecting both to finish together.

Read the ingredient statement for added salt, broth or a solution so you know how the pork was prepared before you bought it. My original rub is very low in salt and works well with brined or enhanced pork, while a heavily salted rub needs more care when the meat has already been salted.

Which Cut Cooks Fastest?

Baby backs often finish sooner, but the name on the package does not tell the whole story, and a very meaty rack can take as long as a thinner rack of spare ribs. Thickness, actual grate temperature, wrapping and the tenderness you want all matter, which is why I use rib cooking times as planning ranges rather than a deadline.

If dinner has to be ready at a certain time, give yourself a reasonable buffer and choose racks that fit your smoker well instead of counting on one cut to save the schedule. A little planning is more useful than discovering halfway through the cook that the lid will not close over your rib rack.

What About Country Style Ribs and Riblets?

Country style ribs are a separate purchase, often cut from the shoulder or loin rather than sold as a slab of rib bones. Shoulder pieces can be cooked until the connective tissue softens, while lean loin pieces need a different approach, so use my country style rib instructions rather than a whole-rack schedule.

“Riblets” is another label worth questioning because it can describe different small rib products, including racks cut across the bones. Ask what the package actually contains, and do not assume every item with that name is the tip section removed from spare ribs.

My Recommendation

For an easy starting point, buy an evenly meaty St. Louis rack and follow the complete pork rib guide, or choose baby backs if that is the cut you already enjoy. Full spares make sense when you want the whole slab or want to learn the trimming process, and none of these choices requires you to change your preference just because another cook likes something different.

Browse All Pork Rib Recipes