The Ultimate Guide to Smokers: Types, Uses, and How to Choose the Best One

I may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

Choosing a smoker gets a whole lot easier once you decide how you want to cook, how much time you want to spend tending a fire and how much food you usually need to fit inside. You can make good barbecue on any of the common smoker types, but they go about producing heat and smoke in different ways.

If you already own a smoker, you don’t have to start over with different equipment to learn something useful here. This guide explains the main cooker types and takes you to the instructions for the one you have, along with the charcoal methods, smoking accessories and maintenance guides that go with it.

How to Use This Smoker Guide

Start with the cooker section that matches your equipment, then follow its link to the complete beginner’s guide. If you’re still deciding what to buy, read the comparisons and how to choose a smoker before worrying about accessories.

For a new cooker, seasoning and the initial burn-in come before the first meal. After that, the guides on temperature control and smoking wood will help you understand the heat and smoke, while shutting down and cleaning finish the job.

What Makes a Smoker Different From a Grill?

A smoker cooks food with heat and wood smoke, usually with the food separated from the direct fire. A grill can do the same job when you arrange it for indirect heat and provide a suitable smoke source, which is why a kettle or gas grill can be useful for smoking even though it isn’t a dedicated smoker.

Smoking doesn’t always mean the lowest possible temperature, and it isn’t limited to tough cuts that need an all-day cook. The setup and temperature should suit the food, whether that means a long pork butt cook or a shorter cook for chicken, turkey breast or pork tenderloin.

The practical differences between cookers are how they generate heat, how they produce smoke, how well you can control the cooking environment and how much attention they need from you.

Pellet Grills

A pellet grill feeds cooking pellets from a hopper into a small fire pot, with a controller managing the fuel feed and fan to hold the cooking temperature. That takes much of the repeated fire tending out of a long cook, although you still need to monitor the food, keep enough dry pellets available and maintain the grease and ash systems.

Many horizontal pellet grills also roast and bake well, while their ability to sear over direct heat depends on the design. Vertical pellet cabinets use the same general fuel system but offer a different arrangement of racks and cooking space, so they shouldn’t be treated as interchangeable with a horizontal grill.

Read How to Smoke on a Pellet Grill for setup, pellets, cooking temperatures and getting useful smoke flavor.

Offset Smokers

An offset has a firebox beside the main cooking chamber, allowing heat and smoke to travel across the food before leaving through the exhaust. Many are run primarily with wood splits over a coal bed, which makes tending the fire a regular part of the cook.

This is a good fit when you enjoy working with a live fire and have the time and space for it. A conventional offset and a reverse-flow offset route heat differently, but both depend on establishing a useful fire and adding fuel before it falls too far behind.

Read How to Smoke on an Offset Smoker for building the coal bed, adding splits and keeping the fire burning cleanly.

Charcoal Bullet and Cabinet Smokers

A conventional charcoal smoker uses charcoal for cooking heat, with wood added for smoke flavor. Bullet smokers, including the Weber Smokey Mountain, and charcoal cabinets can hold a supply of unlit fuel that gradually catches as the fire moves through it.

The amount of charcoal actively burning and the airflow reaching it determine how much heat the cooker produces. Some designs use a water pan or another heat shield between the fuel and the food, and keeping those components in their intended positions is part of learning the cooker.

Read How to Smoke on a Charcoal Smoker for fuel arrangements, airflow and maintaining the cook.

Kettle Grills

A kettle can smoke meat very well when the charcoal is arranged to leave an indirect area for the food. It’s a useful option if you already own one, especially when you want to learn charcoal cooking without making room for another cooker.

The limited grate area means you need to plan how much space the charcoal, food and any drip pan will take up. For longer cooks, a connected charcoal snake or another controlled fuel arrangement can reduce how often you need to add charcoal.

Read How to Smoke on a Kettle Grill for setting up the cooking area and choosing a charcoal arrangement.

Kamado Grills

Kamado cookers use charcoal in a well-insulated body, commonly ceramic, although insulated steel versions also exist. They can maintain low cooking heat with a relatively small fire and can also cook at much higher temperatures when configured for grilling.

For smoking, a heat deflector usually separates the food from the direct fire. Their heat retention is useful during long cooks, but it also means recovering from a large temperature overshoot can take patience, so bringing one up to temperature gradually is worth learning.

Read How to Smoke on a Kamado Grill for lighting, the indirect setup and vent adjustments.

Drum Smokers

A drum smoker holds a charcoal basket beneath the cooking area inside an upright steel body. Depending on the design, food cooks on a grate, hangs from hooks or uses a combination of the two, and some drums let drippings fall onto the coals while others use a diffuser.

Those differences affect the cooking experience, so start with the arrangement your drum was designed to use rather than adding a pan or changing the fire setup simply because another smoker uses one. A hanging cooker also needs enough clearance to keep the food away from the fuel.

Read How to Smoke on a Drum Smoker for grate cooking, hanging, fuel loading and fire management.

Gravity-Fed Charcoal Smokers

A gravity-fed cooker supplies charcoal from a hopper as the fuel beneath it burns. Many backyard versions use a controller and fan to regulate heat, giving you some of the convenience of automatic temperature control while cooking over charcoal.

Although the display can look similar to a pellet grill’s controller, the fuel and shutdown systems work differently. The hopper contains a charcoal fire, and turning off the electronics alone doesn’t necessarily extinguish it.

Read How to Smoke on a Gravity-Fed Charcoal Smoker for lighting, refilling, controller operation and the complete shutdown routine.

Electric Smokers

A typical electric cabinet smoker uses a heating element for cooking heat and a separate wood tray for smoke. The controller handles the element, while you keep track of the food, replenish the wood as needed and manage the water pan if the setup uses one.

This makes an electric cabinet convenient when you want a relatively simple cooking routine. Heating elements cycle on and off, however, so learning how that affects the wood tray helps when the cabinet is hot but a fresh load of chips hasn’t started smoking.

Read How to Smoke on an Electric Smoker for preheating, wood chips, water-pan use and troubleshooting.

Propane Smokers

A propane cabinet uses a gas burner to heat the cooking chamber and wood tray, with racks above the heat source. Many also have a water pan between the burner area and the food.

They’re convenient for cooks who prefer a gas heat source, but the burner flame, wood supply and water level still need attention. Keeping the gas system in sound condition and understanding the lighting routine matter just as much as choosing the knob setting.

Read How to Smoke on a Propane Smoker for preparing the cabinet, lighting the burner and managing wood and water.

Gas Grills Used for Smoking

If your gas grill has room to cook indirectly, you may already have a useful way to smoke smaller meals. Keep the food away from the operating burner’s direct heat and add a suitable smoke source, such as a smoker box, foil packet or pellet tube.

The challenge is keeping enough indirect space while maintaining the temperature you need, especially on a small grill. A grill used this way also loses heat and smoke when the lid is opened, so planning the setup before lighting makes the cook easier.

Read How to Smoke on a Gas Grill for burner arrangements, smoke sources and food placement.

How to Choose the Right Smoker

Start with the cooker you already have if it can do the job. A kettle or gas grill may be enough to find out whether you enjoy smoking meat, and learning on familiar equipment can be more useful than buying something larger before you know what you need.

If convenience is the priority, look at pellet grills, electric cabinets and controller-equipped gravity-fed charcoal cookers, while remembering that automated temperature control still leaves you responsible for the food and the condition of the cooker. If tending a fire is part of what you enjoy, a charcoal cooker or offset gives you more of that hands-on work.

Consider usable cooking space rather than just the total grate-area figure. Think about whether your usual meal is a few pieces of chicken, a full brisket or several racks of ribs, and whether those foods fit without crowding the heat source, walls or airflow passages.

Also consider where the smoker will sit, how you’ll store fuel, whether you have the electrical supply it needs and whether you can comfortably move and clean it. The useful choice is the one that suits the way you actually cook, including the amount of fire tending and cleanup you’re willing to do.

Smoker Comparison at a Glance

Cooker	Heat and control	What to consider
Pellet grill	Pellets; usually automatic fuel and fan control	Convenience, with electrical power and dry pellet storage
Offset	Wood or charcoal; fire tended during the cook	Hands-on fire management and room for fuel
Charcoal bullet or cabinet	Charcoal with added smoking wood	Long cooks with fuel and airflow managed together
Kettle	Charcoal arranged for indirect heat	Making use of a versatile grill with limited grate space
Kamado	Charcoal in a well-insulated body	Smoking and grilling, with gradual temperature adjustments
Drum	Charcoal basket beneath grates or hanging food	A straightforward cooker with a setup specific to its design
Gravity-fed charcoal	Charcoal hopper; many use a controller and fan	Automatic heat control with charcoal-specific fuel and shutdown routines
Electric cabinet	Electric element with a separate wood tray	Simple heat control, with attention to wood and water
Propane cabinet	Gas burner with a separate wood tray	Gas cooking heat, with flame, wood and water monitored
Gas grill	Burners plus a smoker box, packet or tube	Smoking on existing equipment with room for indirect cooking

Charcoal Methods and Fuel Guides

If you’re unsure which fuel to use, start with lump charcoal vs briquettes. For lighting a separate batch, the charcoal chimney guide shows the process with photos.

The Minion method starts with a smaller amount of lit charcoal among a reserve of unlit fuel, while the snake method follows a connected path of charcoal around a suitable grill. They serve a similar purpose during longer cooks, but their arrangements aren’t identical and neither belongs in every cooker.

Two-zone grilling explains how to separate direct and indirect heat on charcoal and gas grills. It describes the cooking areas rather than a particular way of making charcoal burn for hours.

Water Pans and Smoking Accessories

The water-pan guide explains when a pan helps, where it belongs and why plain water is usually the sensible choice. I don’t generally think a water pan is needed on a pellet grill, although the guide covers where I recommend putting a shallow pan if you want to use one.

For a gas grill, learn how to use a smoker box or make a foil woodchip pack. A pellet tube provides another smoke source when it has enough airflow, and can also supplement smoke in other suitable cookers.

Temperature, Airflow and Smoking Wood

Once you have the cooker set up, use the temperature-control pillar for the detailed guides on vents, fuel management and weather. Measuring near the food and finding hot and cold zones will help you understand what is happening across the cooking area.

The Smoking Wood Guide covers wood choices and related techniques, including matching wood to the way your smoker operates and managing a fire for clean smoke. These subjects already have their own guides, so you can follow the part you need without working through the whole series.

Seasoning, Shutdown and Cleaning

Before the first cook, use How to Season a Smoker to understand initial cleaning, oiling where appropriate and the first burn. Ceramic interiors, electrical components and coated surfaces don’t all need the same treatment.

After cooking, follow the routine for your fuel system in How to Shut Down a Smoker, then use How to Clean Your Smoker for cold ash, grease, grates and storage. Keeping those jobs manageable makes it much easier to be ready for the next cook.

You don’t have to master every type of smoker to make good barbecue. Pick the guide that matches your cooker, get comfortable with its normal setup and learn what it does over a few cooks before changing several things at once.

From my backyard to yours

Jeff’s Handcrafted
Seasoning and Sauce

The rubs and sauces I use in my own backyard
and throughout these recipes.

CLASSIC BARBECUE

Original BBQ Sauce

Rich tomato flavor, balanced sweetness and a gentle kick.

$8.99per bottle

Shop Now →

THE SIGNATURE BLEND

Original Rub

Sweet, savory and a touch of heat for your next cook.

$8.99per bottle

Shop Now →

BOLD & PEPPERY

Texas Style Rub

Pepper forward flavor for brisket, steaks and more.

$8.99per bottle

Shop Now →

MUSTARD BBQ SAUCE

Golden Driller

Smooth mustard tang with just the right sweetness.

$8.99per bottle

Shop Now →

Find your next favorite at Thin Blue Foods →