Creative Smoking with Foil Pans
I may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.
Foil pans can make a long day at the smoker a little easier, especially when you want to catch the drippings, keep the cooker cleaner, or carry a finished brisket into the house without leaving a trail behind you.
$19/year
Less than $1.60 a month, billed annually.
Renews yearly until canceled.
Already a member? Log In
The first time I started using them, I wondered whether the pan would keep too much smoke away from the meat, and I wasn't particularly excited about letting the bottom of a brisket or pork butt sit in a puddle of juice for several hours.
After experimenting with a few arrangements, I found that the important decision isn't simply whether to use a pan. It's whether you want the meat resting in the pan or sitting above the liquid.
Should the Meat Sit Directly in the Pan?
You can smoke meat directly in an uncovered foil pan, and the exposed surfaces will still receive smoke. The pan does shield the bottom, though, and as the drippings collect, that part of the meat will sit in the liquid.
That can be useful when you want to retain the cooking juices, but it changes the surface of the meat. If you're shooting for bark around as much of a brisket or pork butt as possible, you may prefer to keep it above the drippings.
Neither arrangement is something you have to use for every cook. Choose the one that fits what you're making and how you want it to turn out.
Use a Rack to Keep the Meat Above the Drippings
A sturdy rack that fits inside the pan gives you a place to support the meat while the juices collect underneath. Make sure the rack is suitable for cooking at your smoker's temperature and strong enough to hold the cut without tipping or sagging.
Get My Free Smoking Chart
Get my printable Smoking Times & Temperatures chart in °F and °C, ready to keep beside the smoker.
The meat should sit high enough that it won't end up resting in the liquid as the pan fills. You also want some room around it rather than wedging a large roast into a pan that barely holds it.
One of my early experiments involved turning a muffin pan upside down inside a larger foil roasting pan. It raised the meat above the juices, but it wasn't the support I wanted for a soft meatloaf. A rack with more even support is a better choice for that job.
Jeff's Tip: Check the fit and stability of your rack and pan before you put the meat on them. That's a much easier adjustment to make while everything is cold.
Rest a Larger Rack Across the Top
Another option is to use a cooking rack that's larger than the foil pan and rest it across the top edges. The meat sits on the rack while the drippings fall into the pan below, keeping it above the liquid without needing a rack that fits inside.

Make sure the rack sits securely and the pan's edges can support the weight without buckling. For heavier cuts, use a sturdy roasting pan or another setup that provides reliable support.
Another Option: Put the Pan Below the Meat
If your smoker has room, you can leave the meat directly on the cooking grate and place a drip pan on a lower rack.

This keeps the meat out of the liquid while catching much of what would otherwise land inside the smoker. It also leaves you with fewer things to work around when you need to check tenderness or move the meat.
Pay attention to where the pan sits, though. Leave room for heat and smoke to move through the cooker, and follow your smoker's instructions about drip pans, water pans, and heat shields. An added foil pan shouldn't block a vent, drain, or another part of the smoker that needs to remain clear.
Use a Second Pan as a Lid
When I want to create a more enclosed cooking environment, I place a second pan of the same size upside down on top of the pan holding the meat. The two rims meet, with the upper pan serving as a lid.
This isn't a tight wrap like wrapping the meat in foil, but it helps keep humidity inside and greatly reduces moisture loss during the covered part of the cook. I've used this setup for brisket and pork butt on many occasions, including my Wooster Brisket.

Handle a Full Foil Pan Carefully
An empty foil pan doesn't weigh much, but a brisket and several cups of hot drippings are another matter. Support the bottom when moving it rather than trusting the thin rim to carry all that weight.
A sturdy sheet pan underneath can make the trip from the smoker to the kitchen easier, provided you have suitable heat protection and a clear place to set it down.
Be careful with knives inside the pan as well. Thin foil is easy to puncture, and a small cut can release the drippings onto the counter before you realize what happened. Move the meat to a cutting board before carving.
Let the Pan Make the Cook Easier
You don't need a foil pan for every recipe, but it's a useful tool when catching drippings or simplifying cleanup matters.
For meat you want to keep above the juices, use a suitable rack inside the pan, rest a larger rack securely across the top, or catch the drippings on a lower shelf. When cooking directly in the pan suits the recipe, that works too.
The idea is to make the pan work for the food you're cooking, and save yourself a little cleanup when supper is over.
Don’t Lose This Article
Enter your email and I’ll send a link to this article straight to your inbox so you can read it anytime.
Join the Smoking Meat Community
Have a question about this technique or want help with your next cook?
Join the conversation with other backyard pitmasters.
From my backyard to yours
Jeff’s Handcrafted
Seasoning and Sauce
The rubs and sauces I use in my own backyard
and throughout these recipes.

CLASSIC BARBECUE
Original BBQ Sauce
Rich tomato flavor, balanced sweetness and a gentle kick.
$8.99per bottle
Shop Now
THE SIGNATURE BLEND
Original Rub
Sweet, savory and a touch of heat for your next cook.
$8.99per bottle
Shop Now
BOLD & PEPPERY
Texas Style Rub
Pepper forward flavor for brisket, steaks and more.
$8.99per bottle
Shop Now
MUSTARD BBQ SAUCE
Golden Driller
Smooth mustard tang with just the right sweetness.
$8.99per bottle
Shop NowFind your next favorite at Thin Blue Foods


