Apple Smoked Chicken in a Pie Pan

Welcome to the  Smoking Meat Newsletter and this week we are going to focus on apple smoked chicken in a pie pan. Why smoke chicken in a pie pan for crying out loud!

Well, as you may have already discovered, there is nothing better than smoked chicken but unless you brine it, the breast meat tends to not be as juicy as it could be.

My wife, for some reason, does not care for chicken that has been brined. I have tried not telling her it’s brined and she can still tell the difference. In her opinion it changes the texture of the meat. I think she is correct to some extent but I still prefer the juiciness that brining adds to the process.

This problem eventually led me to think of a different way, other than brining or injecting, to keep the breast meat juicy and tender.

My solution is to place the chicken in a shallow pie pan which holds the fatty juices that cook out of the chicken. This means the chicken breast is sitting in about 1/2 to 3/4 inch of fatty juice keeping it extremely moist as it cooks.

The pie pan also keeps the chicken in good form which means it keeps the legs and wings tucked real nice even without trussing it.

The shallow pan allows plenty of smoke to get in and around the chicken as well.

I have to tell you that it is a win-win situation for me since my wife said that it might have been one of the best smoked chicken she has had in a while.

I don’t plan to stop brining my chickens completely but this is certainly a great alternative for those who do not prefer the brining. Give it a shot and let me know what you think.

Try the Recipes for My Rub and Sauce..

Many of you have my very own rub recipe and sauce recipe and I highly recommend that you use them on all of the chicken that you smoke but if you don’t have them, then do yourself a huge favor and get them today. They will add a massive amount of flavor to anything you cook and will boost your cooking to a level of success that is unmatched by anything else!

Order Recipes | Read Raving Customer Reviews


Apple Smoked Chicken in a Pie Pan

How to produce consistently tender and juicy smoked chicken with crispy skin (without brining or injecting) by using a pie pan and cooking at slightly higher than normal temperatures.

 Prep Time: 10 minutes | Cook Time: 2 hours 15 minutes | Smoker Temp: 275 F | Meat Finish Temp: 165 | Recommended Wood: Apple

What You’ll Need

  • 1 or more whole chickens
  • Mayonnaise (use the REAL stuff like Hellmann’s)
  • 9-inch pie pans (1 for each chicken)
  • 1/2 stick of real butter (1/8 lb) per chicken (unsalted is fine if you are watching your salt intake)
  • Turkey baster or brush
  • Jeff’s rub and sauce (purchase the recipes here)

Preparing the Chicken for Smoking

Place 1/2 stick of real butter inside of the cavity of each chicken. (this will melt and baste the chicken breast from the inside while it cooks)

Place the chicken(s) breast side down in a 9-inch pie pan

2013-IMG_9855 2013-IMG_9856

I like to use the squeeze mayonnaise to make it easy but that part is totally up to you. Place about 1-2 tablespoons of mayonnaise on top of the chicken.


Using your hands or a basting brush (hands work better), spread the mayonnaise evenly all over the chicken making sure to get it all around the legs, wings, etc.


Sprinkle an ample amount of my rub onto the top and sides of the chicken. My rub is highly flavorful without a lot of salt so you can use as much as you like. It is not overpowering, salty or odd tasting like most other rubs that claim to be “perfect for chicken“.

2013-IMG_9859 2013-IMG_9860

As usual, wait for the rub to get that “wet look” before messing with the chicken too much. This usually takes about 10 minutes.


I did not use the Bradley racks this time but it is a good way to transport the pans of chicken to and from the smoker. I highly recommend a set of these if you don’t have any yet. Check them out at Amazon!

Smoking the Chicken

Prepare your smoker for cooking at 275 degrees F if you can. The higher temperatures will help to crisp up the skin and it will get done a little faster as well.

Note: If your smoker tops out at 225-240 or even less, this is ok but it will take longer and you will either have to be content with less than crispy skin or you will have to finish the chicken on the hot grill or oven to get some crispiness to the skin.

Do the best you can and the flavor will still blow you away once it gets finished.

Because it only takes about 10 minutes to prepare the chickens for smoking, I recommend getting the smoker ready first thing.

You will want to have the smoke going the entire time the chicken is in the smoker for the best flavor and results. If you are using a wood smoker then this is easy but if you are using a charcoal, electric or gas smoker then be sure to have plenty of wood chips, chunks or splits available and keep replacing the wood with new when the smoke stops.

Note: If your smoker has a water pan, use it.

My general recommendation is to use the water pan in your smoker every time you cook unless are making jerky or some other form of dried/dehydrated meat where humidity would hinder the process.

Place the pan of chicken directly on the grates and maintain 275 degrees F until the chicken reaches 165 degrees F in the thickest part of the thigh and/or breast.

Once the juice starts collecting in the pan, use a turkey baster to suck up some of the juices and baste the top of the chicken to keep it moist. Do this at about the 1 hour 30 minute mark and then again at about 2 hours.

Note: Feel free to baste as often as you like as long as your smoker can recover quickly from the lid being opened.


Use a digital probe meat thermometer such as the Maverick ET-732 or an instant read thermometer such as the Thermapen which reads in a mere 3 seconds or less to determine when the chicken is done cooking.

Finishing the Chicken

Once the chicken is finished smoke cooking, the pan will probably be full of juice and you will probably want to remove some of the juice using that turkey baster, before you transport it to the house to prevent spilling it. The juices are excellent for making a nice, slightly smoky gravy for the chicken.

Let the chicken rest for about 10 minutes before carving.

As always, let me know if you have further questions about this recipe and I will try to answer as promptly as possible and/or update the instructions to include the needed information.


Try Jeff’s Recipes for Rub and Sauce

You and I both know that there are a lot of rub and sauce recipes out there and I recommend you try as many different ones as you can but I have a couple of recipes that I personally and painstakingly came up with over the course of about 6 years that I’d love for you to try.

I sell these recipes to help cover the cost of producing the newsletter, to provide hosting for the website, the research and development of new recipes, the service charges for automating the newsletter to more than 200k subscribers, and everything else that we do here to promote the learning of how to smoke meat.

You will find that my rub recipe and sauce recipe are extremely unique, better than anything you ever tasted and if your tastebuds don’t go incredibly nuts over them, I’ll buy them back.

I am very confident that you’ll love them and you’ll not only end up with a couple of wonderful recipes, you’ll feel really good that you helped to support what we do here at in teaching the wonderful art of smoking meat.

Almost every review that I get at the online store is 5 stars and if that don’t make you want to see what all the fuss is about then I don’t know what will.

Here’s one of those reviews that just came in recently from Charlene:

“Tried the rub on Pork Country Style Ribs and it was a raving success. I received so many compliments it was embarrassing. Definitely will be using it again and again”

And here’s an excellent review from Jeremy:

“Smoked pork butt, ribs and chicken, delicious rub, sauce is over the top!”

I receive raving reviews just like these every single day via email and many more are posted at the online store for you to read.

Give the recipes a shot, support the website and impress your friends and family with the amazing flavor of these recipes. I will owe you a debt of gratitude for allowing me to continue do what I love to do.

Order Recipes | Read Raving Customer Reviews Orders

If you enjoy the newsletter and would like to do something helpful, then..

The next time you decide to order something at, use THIS LINK to get there and we’ll get a small commission off of what you purchase.

Thank you in advance for using our special link: