|

Smoked Baby Back Ribs

IMG 8022

In this edition, I am going to explain how to do super tender smoked baby back ribs using a version of the 3-2-1 method which is actually more of a 2-2-1 for baby backs and I am going to show you how to do them the regular way as well which is to leave them on the smoker grate the entire time with no foiling.

Hopefully one of these methods will suit your fancy and help you to produce smoky, succulent ribs that have your friends and family begging for more..

Helpful Information
  • Hands-on Prep Time: 25 minutes
  • Cook Time: 5 hours
  • Smoker Temp: 225-240°F
  • Meat Finish Temp: 195°F or tender to your liking
  • Recommended Wood: Pecan and/or Apple
What You’ll Need
  • 2-3 racks of baby back pork ribs
  • Jeff’s original rub recipe (get the recipes here)
  • Foil and/or a foil pan
Purchasing the Ribs

Baby backs are usually around 2.5 to 3 lbs.. look for slabs that are marked “MINIMALLY PROCESSED” to ensure that they have not been shot up with a lot of saltwater solution and extra flavorings. I also like to see a good bit of fat marbling within the meat.

Baby back ribs top side Baby back ribs bottom side

Preparing the Ribs for Smoking

I keep the prep pretty simple when it comes to ribs.. some folks put the rub on then let them sit overnight in the fridge. That is perfectly fine but you can also just apply the rub right before you smoke them like I often do and that will yield excellent results as well.

As usual, I use my original rub recipe (get the recipes here)

simply because I can’t seem to find anything else that I like. I guess I am spoiled by the awesome flavor and the beautiful mahogany crust that forms on the outside;-)

Before adding the rub though, I highly recommend that you remove the membrane on the bone side of the ribs.

Start by prying up the top layer of plastic-like skin. Then use a paper towel to get a really good grip and pull it clean off.

Note: Some folks use catfish pliers instead of a paper towel to get a grip on that membrane and pull it off. Whatever works for ya’.

Pry up the membrane with a sharp object Pry the membrane up off the bone

Use a paper towel for great grip Pull firmly and steadily to keep from tearing

completely remove the membrane Membrane removed from ribs

Some folks don’t remove the membrane and most restaurants don’t mess with it for obvious reasons of time and effort but in my opinion it lets a lot more smoke get to the meat and I think taking the time to remove it is worth the time and effort required.

ok.. now we can add the seasoning or rub.

Start by mixing up a full batch of Jeff’s original rub recipe (get the recipes here) and don’t taste test too much or you won’t have enough for the ribs. Put the rub into a shaker with fairly large holes like a toothpick dispenser or cheese shaker or you can repurpose a large coarse-ground pepper bottle. They usually have larger holes.

Jeff's Rub RecipeBottles for rub

With the ribs still in the bone-side up position, shake a good covering of rub all over the ribs. The best way I can tell you is to shake enough on there so that you can no longer see the ribs. Here’s what I mean:

Rib bottom covered in rub

Don’t move the ribs, we are waiting for the rub to get a “wet” look and this will take about 10-15 minutes. This is a great time to go get the smoker going or go get something cold to drink, check the score, check your email, etc..

Once the rub has that “wet” look which means it will now stick to the ribs, you can flip them over and rub down the meaty side in the same manner making sure to get full coverage.

Top side of ribs covered in rub

Now that the top side is covered in rub/seasoning, you have to wait for it to get that “wet” look as well. If you procrastinated and didn’t get the smoker going earlier, you really must do that now.

Just as soon as the rub has changed color and is sticking to the ribs, they are ready to smoke. This is how they will start to look when they are almost ready. As you can tell, I got the rub a little heavier in some areas than in others so I’ll give it a little more time.

Rub has a "wet" look to it

You could use a light layer of mustard, oil, etc. to help the rub to stick if you are in a hurry but I prefer to do it naturally if I have time.

Getting the Smoker Ready

You might have a nice wood burning trailer rig or you might just have a charcoal, electric, gas or pellet smoker. Regardless of what you are using, if you will follow my temperature recommendations and my cooking instructions, you should end up with something mighty tasty and especially if you use my original rub recipe. You don’t have to use my recipe but then you’d be missing out on a lot of flavor in my way of looking at things;-)

You’re going to want to get the smoker set up for cooking at about 225°F. This is a very good temperature simply because it will get the ribs done in around 5 hours without burning the rub. I like to use a 50/50 mix of pecan and apple for great smoke flavor.

For this experiment, I used a big old chunk of pecan that I custom cut to fit in my smoke box and piled apple chips in around it to fill in the voids. This will give me solid smoke for about 2.5 hours or so.

Pecan with apple chips

Make sure you are set up for indirect cooking and if your smoker has a water pan, might as well fill it up.

Smoke the Ribs

This is the fun part.. well except for the eatin’ part that is. Once the smoker is clicking along at around 225°F, I am ready to add the ribs to the smoker grate.

For this newsletter, I am going to show you how to cook the ribs in a very normal way and I’m also going to show you how to do them with a 2-2-1 method.

I cooked them both at the same time, but the 1st rack got some extra attention during the process.

What is 2-2-1? Well, I’m glad you asked.. this is the baby back version of the 3-2-1 method designed for smoke cooking spare ribs. The numbers correspond to 3 steps in the process.

  • Step 1 is x number of hours on the grate
  • Step 2 is x number of hours wrapped in foil
  • Step 3 is x number of hours, unwrapped again and back on the grate

Sound confusing? I hope not but if it does, that’s ok. I’ll walk you through it very slowly.

By the way, ribs are one of the few meats that we don’t really have to use a thermometer to tell when it is done. Due to the close proximity of meat to bone, it is more difficult to get a good reading with most thermometers and therefore, we use tenderness to tell us when the meat is done and ready to eat.

Having said that, the digital thermometers made by Thermoworks, and this includes the ThermoPop, the Thermapen and the awesome leave-in thermometer with dual probes called the “Smoke”, all have probes that reduce in size right at the tip and this means you can actually get a decent reading in pork ribs, right between the bones.

You can still cook them as tender as you like but you can also check the temperature and when they get to about 190-195°F, they oughta be pretty darn near perfect.

2-2-1 Method

Step “1”: Once the smoker is going at 225°F and the smoke is starting to roll out, place the ribs bone side down directly on the grate.

Once they have been smoke cooking for 2 hours..

Step “2”: Pull the ribs out of the smoker and wrap them in foil. I like to pour in about 1/4 cup of apple juice just before closing up the foil. Place the wrapped ribs back on the grate as they were before, only this time, in a wrapped configuration.

Been smoke cooking for 2 hoursWrapped in foil

When they have been on the grate, wrapped in foil for 2 hours..

Step “3”: Remove them from the smoker and unwrap them from the foil. You will probably notice that the meat is starting to pull back from the bones and there will be quite a bit of rendered fat in the bottom of the foil.

Been cooking in foil for 2 hours

Place the ribs back on the grate, unwrapped, for 1 more hour to finish cooking.

Notes:

  • Spare ribs use a 3-2-1 method which is identical except the first step requires 3 hours instead of only 2.
  • These times are not etched in stone, you may find with practice, that you prefer to leave them on the grate for a little longer and in the foil a little less. You could end up with something like 2.5-1.5-1 or something similar.

When they are done, which just means they are tender enough for you to make the executive decision that they are ready to eat, slice them up and go after it.

Done and ready to slice All sliced up

Rib bones

My “Normal” Method

What is normal? Well that’s very subjective so we won’t delve into that vein of philosophy but when I am talking about ribs, normal just means that I am going to put them bone side down directly on the grate and pretty much leave them alone until they are done.

Once the smoker is maintaining 225°F and the smoke is flowing out, I place the ribs directly on the grate bone side down. The only time I open the door is to add more water, wood chips/chunks or to check progress occasionally.

I fully expect these to take about 5 hours so I’m gonna find something else to do while they cook and let the smoker do it’s thing for a while.

To check and see if they are done, I am looking for a certain level of tenderness. For me, this is not quite “meat falling off the bone”but it’s pretty close. For you it might be something else.

I like to grab the ribs on one end with a pair of tongs and lift them up a little. The amount of bend I get on the other end tells me how tender they are. If they start to break in half, they are considered “fall-off-the-bone” which might be just the way you like them and that is perfectly fine with me.

My usual method for checking doneness is to slice one off and take a bite.. I can tell pretty quick if it’s “there” yet.

"normal" ribs done "normal" ribs sliced

Just so you know..

There are a lot of folks out there saying that if your ribs are really tender to the point of falling off the bone, that they are way over done and are not fit to eat. This is true (unfortunately) for official barbecue competitions but not for cooking at home. Those of you who know me, know that I am a “no rules” kind of guy when it comes to these things. If it tastes good and your friends and family like it then who am I to tell you what the rules are.

If you like the meat falling off the bone then that’s how you should prepare them.


Order Jeff’s Rubs and Barbecue Sauce TODAY!

✅ My rubs and sauce will be the best thing you’ve ever tasted and it’s a great way to support what we do!

Note: You can also order the formulas for my rubs and sauce and make these yourself at home. Grab those HERE and download immediately.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

14 Comments

  1. Quick question, you mention adding water during the “regular” smoke, but no mention of water during the 2-2-1 smoke. Do you put water in the smoker during the 2-2-1 smoke?

    1. My normal recommendation is to always add water or other liquid if your smoker is equipped with a water pan. The only time I don’t do this is if I am having trouble creating a nice crust due to excess moisture in the air. This happens in some electric smokers due to limited airflow. I also sometimes forego the water pan if I am drying meat as in making jerky.

  2. Please describe the flavor of your rub recipe. I am looking for a sweet rub as opposed to the common spicy variety.

    1. The original rub recipe is a great balance of sweet and spicy. You can make it less spicy by adjusting a couple of ingredients and I am always happy to help with this.

  3. For those having trouble making tender ribs, check your temperatures. I finally got a remote thermometer and found my electric smoker was 25 degrees too cool. I just did my first batch of baby backs and they were perfect with the 2-2-1 method. I had to set 250 to get 225. Temperatures are key.

  4. Please help! I have tried the 2-2-1 method for my baby backs and every time it turns out poorly. I have an electric smoker and keep trying the rib recipe. Actually the best luck I have is cooking in the oven covered.

    I am about to give up on smoking them…one more time this weekend…I feel like I am just wasting money buying the ribs and smoking them.

    Please … Any suggestions?

    Thanks in advance

  5. Thanks for all the info. I love your rub as well.

    I have a RecTec pellet smoker. I hear that you shouldn’t smoke ribs past the 2nd hour or so. When I take the ribs out of the foil for the final hour, I cannot turn off the smoke. Is it true? What should I do?

    1. This is not really true.. in real wood smokers where wood is the heat source and the smoke by default, there is no way to turn off the smoke and there is no better smoked meat anywhere. You can wrap it in foil to protect it from the smoke but this is not really necessary. Keep plenty of airflow into and out of your smoker and you can add smoke for the entire time with great end results.

      Having said that, you don’t have to add smoke for the entire time if you don’t want to and some folks find that they prefer adding smoke very lightly for a short period of time. Some like a more subtle smoke flavor while others like it more pronounced. Both ways are correct and it just depends on your personal preference.

  6. Do you keep the smoke going for the full 5 hours when doing your normal method or for only part of the time?

  7. Hey Jeff!
    I tried the 2-2-1 method for baby back ribs just as described in this article and I didn’t have an luck? My ribs were really tough and had to be cut off with a knife. I know it has to be something I did wrong because I have found most people love that method for cooking ribs. I am using an electric smoker by the way. What do I need to do get my ribs to fall off the bone? cook longer?
    Any help would be great!
    Thanks,
    Austin

  8. I plan on making some baby backs this weekend. I plan on following the steps you recommend in this article to see if I can improve on my ribs. Currently my friends and family love my ribs, but I’d also like to see if I can get them to competition grade. As you said home cooking and tournament cooking a completely different. Do you have an article that would detail how you would prepare these ribs for a competition? I would really appreciate seeing how the final products differ.

      1. Jeff,

        I have been using your rub and sauce recipe for 2 years now. I bought ribs at my local Dillons that were already rubbed and I added some of your rub just to be safe. I didn't like the way that they turned out, so I went to my local Sams Club and bought a 3 pack of Baby backs to try again this weekend. I am sure that with your rub exclusively, that they will be the bomb. I also purchased a Pitmaster IQ110 temp controller for my smoker. I am going to put it on my Weber Gold 22.5 grill and use it to smoke these. Shouldn't be an issue and I am looking forward to having some killer bbq. Thank again Jeff.