Pimento Cheese Stuffed Jalapenos
Smoking-Meat.com is supported by its readers. We may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you if you buy through a link on this page.
I recently came up with the idea for pimento cheese stuffed jalapeños but it’s only a slight deviation from the typical cream cheese and cheddar stuffed jalapeños that we usually make.
In both versions, the pepper is stuffed then wrapped in a piece of bacon and smoked until the bacon is crisp and the jalapeño is soft.
Give this a try SOON!
- Prep Time: 45 minutes
- Cook Time: 3 hours
- Smoker Temp: 225-240°F
- Meat Finish Temp: N/A
- Recommended Wood: Maple or Cherry
- Pimento cheese (homemade or store-bought)
- Jeff’s original rub
- Bacon, thin cut is best*
*Most thin cut bacon will have about 13-16 slices per pound but you should probably count them while you are in the store to make sure you get enough. The more slices per pound = the thinner the bacon.
Cut the peppers in half length-wise leaving the stem on each piece for a handle.
Use a spoon to remove the pith (white stuff) and seeds. I “borrowed” a teaspoon from Abi’s kitchen and sharpened the edges with a file to make this job easier. (maybe she won’t notice😉)
The sharpened spoon made a quick job of it. You can also use a grapefruit spoon if you have one of those.
I did not make my own pimento cheese but rather bought a few different kinds to see if it made a difference in the end.
Note: For the Tulsa locals.. I found all of these pimento cheeses at Reasors. Places like Krogers, Safeway, Food Lion, etc. should also have a few good selections as well and/or if you happen to make your own.. that would be awesome as well.
On the left is the basic store brand. The next one is more fancy and has added jalapenos (why not, right?). The third one is also fancy but is just the classic pimento with nothing extra added in.
I tasted of each of these before stuffing the jalapenos and there was a definite difference in the fancy ones vs the basic.. much better flavor but I still wasn’t convinced I’d be able to tell that once they were stuffed, wrapped in bacon and smoked.
There’s no right or wrong way to do this.. just use a spoon to get the mixture into the half pepper boats.
I used the containers to let me know which peppers where stuffed with which type of pimento. I later marked the types on the side of the pan.
Cut the bacon in half if your peppers are small to medium. If you get hold of some that are large or extra large, you may need a whole piece of bacon for each ABT.
I made mine work with a half slice but several of them really needed a whole slice and I should not have been so stingy with it!
All of the peppers filled and wrapped and looking right “purdy”!
Give them a good sprinkle of my original rub and they are ready for the smoker.
Key: FJ= Fancy with jalapeno, F= Fancy classic, C=Cheapo
Set up your smoker for cooking at about 225-240 °F using indirect heat. If you are using a pellet smoker like I did, the lower the heat the more smoke you will get so you will want to opt for a temperature of 220-225°F for at least the first hour and then you can turn them up if you want to.
If you have a smoker that uses a water pan, fill it up.
Once the smoker is ready, place the peppers on the smoker grate.
I like to use a pan with a rack to make it really easy to insert and remove the peppers from the smoker.
These will take about 3 hours for the pepper to get really soft and the bacon to crisp up. Use your best judgement and call them done when they are perfect.
These were all utterly delicious.. I could not tell the difference in the various types of pimento although my wife and youngest daughter claimed the fancy was much better than the cheapo. Try it and let me know what you think.
Get some help
Solicit a few other people to help with this. If you set up an assembly line where someone is cutting stems, a couple of folks are coring and then someone is cutting them in half, etc. it’s much easier.
I was an engineer (IE & ME) in a previous life so this appeals to me.. the person removing the stems could also be cutting them in half to balance out the work and reduce bottlenecks.
If you only have one other helper, perhaps one could remove the stem and core while the next person cuts them in half and stuffs. You could then work together to wrap with bacon.
As you can see, this can be engineered down to a well oiled machine..
Reduce the “hotness”
If jalapeños are just too hot for some, you can soak them in sprite or some other lemon lime soda for a couple of hours once the seeds and veins are removed. You can do this whole or in halves.. works great either way.
Some of the spiciness will leach out into the soda and the peppers will become more mild. The longer you soak, the more mild they become.
Save the soda to use when marinating chicken or some other meat.. it will give them a nice jalapeño flavor.
I know some of you are wondering.. I have no idea if you can use other types or flavors of soda. I heard about this trick several years ago and it worked so I figure if it’s not broke…
Finding thin bacon
As I mentioned, anytime you are wrapping things in bacon for the smoker, thin bacon usually works best.
Bacon is usually not labeled as “thin” but what you can do is count the slices to see how thin it is. If you find a pound size package of bacon and it has 13-16 slices, it is cut fairly thin. The more pieces of bacon in the pound package, the thinner the bacon.Print
Pimento Cheese Stuffed Jalapenos
- Prep Time: 45 minutes
- Cook Time: 3 hours
- Total Time: 3 hours 45 minutes
- Category: Appetizer
- Cuisine: Hot Smoking
- 12 jalapeños
- 16 oz pimento cheese
- 1/4 cup Jeff’s original rub
- 2 lbs bacon, thin-cut
- Cut peppers in half lengthwise leaving part of the stem on each piece. Scrape out/remove the seeds and white parts inside the jalapeños.
- Use storebought or homemade pimento cheese to stuff peppers full and slightly heaped up. Sprinkle liberally with Jeff’s original rub.
- Depending on the diameter of the pepper boats, wrap full or half-slices of bacon around each pepper beginning on one end and slightly overlapping until you get to the other end. Secure with a toothpick if necessary. Give them another sprinkle with Jeff’s original rub, then set them aside while you get the smoker ready.
- Set up your smoker for cooking at 225°F (107°C) using indirect heat and your favorite hardwood for smoke. We recommend maple or cherry. If your smoker uses a water pan, fill it up.
- When the smoker is ready, place the peppers on the smoker grate and close the lid/door.
- Cook for about 3 hours or until the bacon is crisp and peppers are soft.
- Remove and serve immediately.
Order Jeff’s Rubs and Barbecue Sauce!
✅ My rubs and sauce will be the best thing you’ve ever tasted and it’s a great way to support what we do!
Did you know? You can order the MASTER FORMULAS which allow you to make Jeff’s rubs and barbecue sauce at home using your own ingredients! Order the Recipes
Who knew pimento cheese could add so much to ATB’s? Well, Mr. Phillips, you obviously do. And now I do too. Amazing! I was skeptical as I like to include some kind of meat in my ATB’s, but I was not at all disappointed. Will do again.
As with every recipe and technique that I have tried, this one did not disappoint. I have used Jeff’s Pastrami, Tri-tip, other bacon wrapped Jalapenos and other for events at the residential youth ministry that I work at. They always result in requests for repeats. And there are always request for “my” rub recipe. I tell there where to get it.
In the notes, Jeff say that other flavors of soda might work other than Sprite or that type of lemon flavoring. Today I began preparing the peppers and realized that I did not have any Sprite. There was a large bottle of Lemon and a bunch of Diet Coke. It worked just fine.
Thanks for all of the support and teaching, Jeff.
We were going to do some jalapeno poppers last weekend and I saw this recipe. We split our jalapenos and did half with the standard and half with pimento cheese. What a mistake! The next time, we go full on pimento cheese in all. It really added a great taste and touch of class to the poppers! Excellent recipe.
My partner found some jalapeno velveeta, which I’m going to use for my next batch in a few days.